Says the Forest to the Girl – A Review

Says the Forest to the Girl. Sally Rosen Kindred. (Porkbelly Press, 2018) 40 pages.  $10.00 at

Review by William Shaw

Says the Forest to the Girl by Sally Rosen Kindred offers a taut, visceral, and surprisingly funny take on fairy tales and the women embodied by them. It stands in the feminist tradition of re-appropriated folk tales alongside Angela Carter’s The Bloody Chamber. Like Carter, Kindred’s work is inventive and empowering, because of, and not in spite, of its consistent sense of the otherworldly.

The title poem is evocative and unnerving, with shades of the gothic conveying a sense of intergenerational predation:

Am a ladder of ravens.

Am blazon and bloom.

Bones in a stem: your mother’s bones.

Things get creepier when the forest proclaims:

Want your sleep’s thick

castle, its fruit-weight

to fill me. Will tell you a story if you’ll just lie still.

And yet the poem’s ending is ambivalent, implying both a connection with ancestry and a sinister putting-to-sleep:


is the story: to wake

you must claim it, crow-close in the telling. Climb

in. Lid to root. Am singing you down.

More playful, but equally imaginative, is “Said Rapunzel to the Wolf.” The poetic voice drolly notes that “My story cried out for a wolf.” But the poem’s whimsy facilitates a mature reflection on injustice, grounded in the visceral:

My story starts in the throat.

The throat is a tower: the story climbs out

of that red cage, personal, burning

The chapbook’s final two poems are even more explicit in their reclaiming of the narrative. In “Little Red: Morning,” the poetic voice reflects:

Nobody ever told me a story

where the woman’s

body, mean and squinting, gets


While “I Tell What Kind of Girl” concludes:

Through the white door

she could hear

the pinched hearts of asphodel —

and then it opened

like mercy, like breath

when she began to tell.

The reference to “asphodel” suggests the Elysian fields — the protagonist’s fate is decidedly ambiguous — but it is resolutely hers, and it marks a powerful ending to the chapbook. Says the Forest to the Girl is a rich and finely-worked collection; its best images linger like a bloodstain on the snow.

William Shaw is a writer and poet from Sheffield, England. His writing has appeared in Star*Line, Space & Time, Imperica, and Doctor Who Magazine. His first book, The Black Archive #42: The Rings of Akhaten, is available from Obverse Books. You can find him on Twitter @Will_S_7 

Poet? Publisher? We review speculative poetry! Send a query with your upcoming title to and we’ll take it from there.

New to THE SPECk? Want more? Go to this happy place and subscribe to THE SPECk, the SFPA Insider Newsletter. It’s free.

The SFPA is a global poetry organization supported and sustained by its members. It is celebrating its 42nd anniversary. Becoming a member of the SFPA not only helps us continue to connect speculative poetry to the world, but is also comes with some pretty cool benefits.
Joining is easy! Visit:

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.